Are these buttons going to work?

[ClareInStitches]

I am making a light weight cotton blouse and have found that I have buttons of the perfect number, dimensions and colour in my stash. Good Heavens, I hear you cry, That's a first!

Any way, they have a little oval shank on the back, rather than two holes. Will I be trying to do the impossible if I use them on my blouse? Will the shank always push the fabric apart so that the fabric won't lie flat? Is there a buttonhole made for this style of button?   

Many thanks for your thoughts,
Clare.

[BrendaP]

@ClareInStitches   Make your sample buttonholes on scraps of the bllouse fabric - as you would normally do - and sew buttons onto a separate piece of the same fabric (folded and with the same interfacing etc) and then fasten them together and see how you think they look.

[Iminei]

Ive always wondered about these buttons with a shank too ...

Why are they like made like this? and can you only attach them by hand-stitching ??

[dolcevita]

Ive always wondered about these buttons with a shank too ...

Why are they like made like this? and can you only attach them by hand-stitching ??

Buttons with a shank are good for thicker or more layers of fabric. If I'm sewing a button with holes onto something that's a bit thicker, e.g. a jacket, I will hold the button away from the fabric by a few millimetres whilst sewing it on, then wind the thread around the thread loops between the button and the fabric to form a shank. The shank gives room for the thickness of the buttonhole layer to sit under the button without squeezing it or pulling it. I don't know if there's a machine to sew on a shank button, but it's probably not that much quicker by the time you've messed around with securing the ends.

[Bodgeitandscarper]

Are you worried the shank will open up the buttonhole?  I wonder if a buttonhole with a rounded end would be better, so the shank sits at that end?

[Iminei]

Thank you @dolcevita 

[dolcevita]

Not sure if it helps, but here are a couple of photos of the shank buttons on one of my blouses. I used them because I liked the pearl effect rather than because they are shank buttons.
  [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]  

   [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]  

[ClareInStitches]

Many thanks for all of your posts.

I shall try BrendaP's suggestion and 'audition' the buttons with a trial button hole and see if I like it.  I see that my machine has a couple of buttonhole designs and I'll give those a go too. As Bodgitandscarper said, a rounded end might suit better.

You have been a great help. Thank you.

Clare