I made a dress very much like this, by combining the sleeves, back and skirt of a the shirt dress from a Gertie book. When the original pattern failed, and I took those pieces, and then used my Singer Plus blouse pattern, using the front and the back (to create a yoke) pattern pieces to create the top part. I fashioned the waistband, for the front, and then put it all together. It worked out, as well as being comfortable. Unlike the mccalls pattern, the back waist is elasticised, which adds to the comfort level.