The Sewing Place

Tools of the Trade => The Haberdashery => Topic started by: sewingj on January 23, 2020, 16:54:03 PM

Title: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: sewingj on January 23, 2020, 16:54:03 PM
I know there is a golden rule that you mustn't use dressmaking scissors to cut paper - and I don't. But I must admit that I wonder if this is an outdated rule stemming from the days when scissor blades weren't as robust as they are now.
I fail to see how scissors that happily slice through some chunky tweed would be damaged by a sheet of paper!
Educate me please!
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: BrendaP on January 23, 2020, 17:10:27 PM
Paper contains all sorts of addatives, including clay and other minerals which are not in fabric, so that's why using scissors on paper is not good. 

Paper shouldn't damage good scissors irreparably (unless you cut over staples etc) but they will dull and need sharpening sooner.  Synthetic fabrics will dull the blades quicker than natural fabrics and paper will dull them sooner than synthetics.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: WendyW on January 23, 2020, 19:00:01 PM
I've read elsewhere that it is a myth- that paper does no more damage than some fabrics. That said, I will NEVER let my family in on that secret, because once they get it into their heads that sewing scissors do not HAVE to receive special consideration, the scissors will never be safe again. They would be at risk to cut ANYthing that needs cutting, which WILL cause damage, and then I would have to damage a family member, and I'd rather not do that. Some myths, like Santa Clause, simply must be encouraged.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Starryfish on January 23, 2020, 19:27:14 PM
Cutting out pdfs has made a pair of my scissors all sticky with the tape holding the pages together!
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Greybird on January 23, 2020, 20:56:27 PM
As an engineer's daughter I was brought up to never let blades anywhere near paper - it's made of wood. My dad used to show me blades under a magnifying glass that had been damaged by incorrect use. I have "kitchen drawer" scissors that are used to cut paper and woe betide anyone that uses any other scissors for that job.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Pearl on January 23, 2020, 21:41:26 PM
Not sure if I’ve told you about my proudest parenting moment.

DD:  Please do you have any scissors I could use?
Me:  You can use those ones with the orange handles.
DD:  Aren’t they your fabric scissors?
Me:  No, they’re fine.

Enter DS1. Looks in horror at DD

DS1:  Aren’t they Mum’s fabric scissors?

I’ve trained them well.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: annieeg on January 23, 2020, 22:35:02 PM
@Greybird
I have exactly the same policy - kitchen scissors and paper cutting scissors kept out of the sewing room. 
I've had a pair of fabric cutting scissors from when I did my City and Guilds in 1990 which are still perfectly fit for purpose 0_0
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: wrenkins on January 24, 2020, 07:41:54 AM
Why risk it?  :o

Him indoors once pretended to lift my scissors to open something. He just wanted to see my reaction apparently. Turns out it was even better than he'd anticipated.  0_0 He's a retired farrier so there's little I can teach him about metal things.  8)
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: sewingj on January 24, 2020, 08:21:35 AM
I'm still not convinced. I think viscose is made from wood as much as paper is, and other fabrics must have all sorts of additives. I think it's mainly a myth maintained by sewists to stop their family borrowing their scissors to open paint tins (for example!)
I'm quite happy to go along with it!
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Lowena on January 24, 2020, 10:02:15 AM
I used scissors from my sewing room to open a tin of paint yesterday.
I have 3 pairs of scissors which I use for everything and anything.
Mind you, I only do p&q so I use a rotary cutter mostly
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: BrendaP on January 24, 2020, 10:20:13 AM
I used scissors from my sewing room to open a tin of paint yesterday.
I have 3 pairs of scissors which I use for everything and anything.
Mind you, I only do p&q so I use a rotary cutter mostly

Will any of your scissors snip a dangling thread, ie no tension on the thread?
Will any of your scissors cut (P&Q weight) fabric along the full length of the blade?

At craft club a few months ago someone had put about a dozen pairs of scissors onto the sales table.  Lily, the lady in charge is very good at selling you something you didn't know you wanted, but as she only charges peanuts....  We often show someone our purchas and say "I've been Lilyed!  But on that occasion she was hacking away at a bit of fabric to try and tell me that the scissors were good.  They weren't!  I tried them all and bought one pair which was OK for paper.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: BrendaP on January 24, 2020, 10:21:52 AM
I have just received a timely email from Ernest Wright pointing to this advice. (https://www.ernestwright.co.uk/looking-after-your-scissors/?mc_cid=82226d14be&mc_eid=4e3cf2b2b7)
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Iminei on January 24, 2020, 11:45:30 AM
Ahem !!!  :[   I seem to have ... ahem .. somehow put my kitchen scissors together wrongly and they are now ... ahem ... well and truly stuck !!!

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]  

I have no idea how on earth I managed to do this ......  they went together as they usually do, perfectly easily with no stress but now they might as well be superglued together!

I'm going to take them to our local repair cafe next month to give all the volunteers there a good laugh!
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: coffeeandcake on January 24, 2020, 12:14:04 PM
Several years ago DH used my fabric scissors for cutting some paper. He only did it once and had to buy me a new pair :P
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: HenriettaMaria on January 24, 2020, 12:35:39 PM
"A tiny drop of household oil (or vegetable oil) can help too"  :o

What are they saying?  Are they quite mad?  You should NEVER use edible oils to lubricate machinery of any kind (nor should you use mineral oil to dress a salad)!  The only thing edible and mineral oils have in common is that they are insoluble in water.  Edible oils are, chemically, triglycerides, which are big E-shaped molecules.  Mineral oils are hydrocarbons, ie, chains of carbon atoms with hydrogen atoms attached, the smallest of which is the gas you cook with.  By the time you get to eight carbon atoms you're in petrol territory and they get more viscous and 'oily' the more carbon atoms there are.

The upshot of this is that edible oils, being edible, will be digested by any passing bacterium and will go rancid, sticky and disgusting.  Mineral oil will evaporate slowly and, if it's the correct type for the machine in question, shouldn't leave a chemical residue although bits of worn-off bearings, fabric fibres, etc, might cause a bit of a mess if the machine isn't maintained.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Acorn on January 24, 2020, 13:58:57 PM
Does that mean I was right to use a smidge of WD40 on my scissors?   ><
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Lowena on January 24, 2020, 14:02:36 PM
I use WD 40 on everything :D........not salads though
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: WildAtlanticWay on January 24, 2020, 14:23:17 PM
I used scissors from my sewing room to open a tin of paint yesterday.

 :o

I have several pairs of expensive hairdressing scissors (£200+ each) so I’m very careful with all my scissors. DH always has to check even when using the scissors from the kitchen drawers.  ;)
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: HenriettaMaria on January 24, 2020, 15:52:21 PM
Does that mean I was right to use a smidge of WD40 on my scissors?   ><

Yes, it's not edible!
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Kwaaked on January 24, 2020, 16:05:53 PM
Well, I have a pair of pattern cutting scissors that I have to sharpen twice a year due to dullness.  I also have a pair of carpet shears that I use on denim that need the same.

My regular scissors and shears get it once a year.  My tailor points go every 2, not because I don't dull them, but I have 4 pairs.

Paper and heavy fabric=dull scissors in my experience.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: JudyN on January 25, 2020, 16:15:05 PM
My mum's bread knives were never the same after my brother and I used them for making dens out of large cardboard boxes....
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: wrenkins on January 25, 2020, 16:38:57 PM
 :S Did you make windows @JudyN? How very pan-loafy!  0_0
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: JudyN on January 25, 2020, 17:20:36 PM
:S Did you make windows @JudyN? How very pan-loafy!  0_0

Yup, and doors! We knew how to entertain ourselves back in those days!
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Marniesews on February 03, 2020, 23:37:02 PM
Well, I must admit I raised an alarmed eyebrow during Janet Pray's Bluprint class on Industry Secrets (or it might have been the Advanced Techniques one) when she said in 'the Industry' tailors placed the card patterns on their fabric and cut through paper and fabric together with their weighty shears. According to her it is was common practice and no harm came from it. She recommends this as a good technique for home sewers too. It was one of the titular 'secrets' she shared.

I did wonder though, how often those factories arranged a visit from the scissor sharpening man (must be missing a technical term here, cutler doesn't seem right) and had all their scissors serviced on a regular basis. If they had need of multiple pairs of scissors, this probably made commercial sense rather than having multiple pairs for different uses. I have seen people hailed as highly skilled seamstresses sewing with a great beast of a pair of scissors at their side that they seem to use for everything, including thread snips.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Nevis5 on February 05, 2020, 06:59:27 AM
I'm very lucky as I'm the only left handed one in the house and all my scissors are proper left handed ones.  Years of nagging means that they know not to touch  :devil:

Luckily, when my nutty elder sister decided to trim the lawn edging WITH MY SNIPPY SCISSORS she stole the old blunt ones I use for paper.  Otherwise she may no longer be in possession of ten fingers and thumbs  :devil:
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: snoozi soozi on February 21, 2020, 11:56:20 AM
Is this too careful?  0_0

  [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]  
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Gernella on February 21, 2020, 12:04:29 PM
Ahem !!!  :[   

I'm going to take them to our local repair cafe next month to give all the volunteers there a good laugh!

What is one of those? We could do with something like that around here or at the very least a little man who can mend anything.
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Vezelay on February 21, 2020, 17:54:20 PM
https://repaircafe.org/en/visit/
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Lowena on February 22, 2020, 02:47:12 AM
None in Norfolk at all  :'(
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Lilian on February 22, 2020, 19:13:13 PM
https://repaircafe.org/en/visit/

Thanks for the link @Vezelay I had never heard of a repair cafe, and guess what there is one opened in my nearest town just 4 miles out of my village  :)  :vintage:
Title: Re: Are we too careful with our scissors?!
Post by: Helen M on February 22, 2020, 19:58:18 PM
There's one where I live, have seen notices in the free local magazine. Think the next one is quite soon.