Which buttons?

[realale]

I'm too mean cheap frugal to want to buy any buttons when I have so many in my personal resource centre. However, this dress needs at least 12 buttons which again knocks down my choices. So, I've got 4 ideas - can you please let me know which you prefer.

[SewRuthieSews]

Hah yes I would be the same.

My favourite is number 4.

[Acorn]

Same here - number 4.   

[Lowena]

Number 4

[Vezelay]

No 2 or no 4. It's going to be a lovely dress!

[Starryfish]

No 4.

[Bodgeitandscarper]

Another vote for number 4.

[b15erk]

Definitely number 4! 

Jessie

[Ouryve]

I like the lighter colour ones, whichever number they are.

[Ploshkin]

4

[twopence]

3 for me like @Ouryve

[Puzzler]

2 or 4.

[Ellabella]

3 or 4

[mudcat]

I'm a 2 or 4 (black "design" buttons) as I think they add a nice touch to the solid color.  The first ones are too plain and to my eyes the lighter 3 isn't quite right with that red.

[BrendaP]

3 as first choice, 4 as second choice.